Absurd to pick 4 looseheads

Given that tighthead prop is a position highlighted by Heyneke Meyer as one lacking in depth, Tank Lanning finds it absurd that Heyneke Meyer can only find space for 2 of them in a 36 man squad.

Tank Lanning in his column for Sport24

This year’s Currie Cup final was extraordinary in so many ways. Primarily because it was such an entertaining game between the two sides who have embraced a more attacking approach. Perhaps expected from the Lions, but less so from a side dubbed “The wall of Cape Town” while masquerading as the defence orientated Stormers during Super Rugby.

It has taken a while, but it really is truly heartening to see South African rugby (including that from the Boks) embracing the more ball in hand, heads up game played by the New Zealand sides. The game’s survival depends on it being entertaining enough to entice the public to spend their hard earned (and shrinking) disposable sheckles on it, and people want to see offloads in the tackle to a fullback running the perfect line, not 2 flyhalves kicking the dimples off a ball for 80 minutes.

Players also enjoy it more. It was great to see Warren Whiteley and Juan de Jongh run onto Newlands with smiles on their faces.

Coach Johan Ackermann deserves every ounce of credit coming his way for what he has done with the Lions, but then so does new Western Province Director of Rugby, Gert Smal. Implementing change is not easy. Doing so using existing staff and players is even tougher. He has been the needed breath of fresh air in the Cape, and quite obviously has a management style that both players and coaches enjoy. Now to see if he can make this brand of rugby work at Super Rugby level …

A few people questioned my sanity when I credited the WP scrum for the win in the now traditional Sunday morning banter on Twitter. This given the penalties awarded to the Lions come scrum time, and the fact that the Lions still probably edged that battle.

But given what the Lions did to the Sharks in their semi final a week before, where luminaries such as Matt Stevens, Thomas du Toit, Dale Chadwick and Lourens Adriaanse were used as a plough to dig up Ellis Park with their retreating studs, how the WP pack kept that juggernaught Lions scrum in check was simply remarkable.

Not known for their scrumming dominance this season, I thought all of Alistair Vermaak (who really has come of age this year), Pat Cilliers and Brok Harris were a superb in blunting what was a key Lions weapon. And that would have resonated hugely with both teams, positively for WP, and negatively for the Lions.

One could compare it to how the Boks and All Blacks handled the mighty Argentinean Bajada. The Bok scrum got decimated and the team thus struggled hugely in both games. While the All Blacks still came second come scrum time, but marginally, and certainly not to the extent that their own scrum ball was not usable.

And even with a few controversial scrum penalties going against them (I find it tricky to believe that a scrum in survival still has the ability to wheel it intentionally), the WP scrum kept their side in the game, while at the same time sowing a few seeds of doubt in the minds of the Lions players.

That said, given the outstanding performance of the Lions scrum this season (especially in Super Rugby), both Julian Redelinghuys and Robbie Coetzee are deserving of their Bok call ups.

That Redelinghuys is one of only 2 tighthead props in a 36 man squad is quite ridiculous, though. Surely a fantastic opportunity to give the other tighthead who has performed so well for the Lions this year, Ruan Dreyer, a chance to experience the Bok culture? Especially given that it is a position highlighted by the coach as one lacking the depth he would like.

Instead we see 4 loosehead props in the squad, including the proven to be surplus to company requirements Gurthro Steenkamp. Enter stage right, the heart burn inducing sight of either Coenie Oosthuizen or Trevor Nyakane being used on the wrong side of the scrum. Why do we not learn from previous experiments gone wrong?

I would have had perhaps the most under rated player in SA, Lions loosehead Schalk van der Merwe in place of Oosthuizen at loosehead, and Dreyer in as a tighthead at the expense of Steenkamp.

It rewards form and players choosing to play in SA, and renders a much more balanced squad. To my mind, it seems an obvious call.